Creative Pizza Toppings
I’m pretty sure I’m not alone in using pizza a fall back dinner option. Especially if you are talking delivery. How often are you truthfully thrilled with your delivery pizza? I know we appreciate it because it was a respite from heating up the house with oven or stove or because we didn’t have do anything more than dial the phone, sign the receipt and get the plates out of the cupboard. But as a culinary treat they usually fail in some way or another. We’ve had under-baked crusts, pesto pizzas literally swimming in olive oil, artichoke hearts with the tough layer still attached waiting to gag you, un-drained pineapple and roasted red peppers, raw and undercooked mushrooms and onions. You name a possible pizza problem and it has probably knocked on our door.
The best pizza treat around these parts is when we make our own. It is always hot and fresh. As long as we chose a good crust recipe, the crust is fully cooked and appropriately crispy for the thickness. Homemade pizza also allows us to get a bit creative with the toppings, something DH really appreciates since not all pizza places are created equal in their offerings for vegetarians. Over a month ago now we invited a friend over to enjoy an evening of grilled pizza on the patio. We had the fixings for three really unusual pizzas and one only slightly different pizza.
Probably the most unique one we made had roasted beets and onions (a bit saved from making the warm beet and lentil salad), some chopped walnuts and a sprinkling of Gorgonzola cheese. All three of us liked it. It is a very different taste for pizza. Though I think we all agreed that it was not one you would want to eat alone as your only type of pizza. I like beets pretty well though so I might be okay with that and a generous side salad. It would depend on my mood.
Next up was a pizza inspired by a casserole (or tartlette) recipe from Olive Trees and Honey (a cookbook that I cannot recommend enough, even if you aren’t vegetarian or Jewish) that Drew likes to make fairly regularly. A week or two before this pizza night we had made the same filling, but put it into my Fatayer crust for eggplant pasties. It was the first time we had actually roasted the eggplant on the grill and we were blown away by the difference that made, even on a gas grill.
So, we did it once again for this pizza, though it wasn’t charred as much so didn’t have quite the smokiness of the pasties. The crust was brushed lightly with some olive oil that was gently heated with several smashed cloves of garlic to infuse it. Then we spread the roasted and chopped eggplant on top, added a sprinkling of salty feta and a bit of cheddar cheese. The result was slightly smokey, very hearty (almost meaty) and really, really good! We’ll definitely be revisiting that in the future, even in the winter when we roast in the oven I presume. I wouldn’t mind a bit of sauteed onion and some black pepper in the mix too.
This one is simple at the core. It is your basic cheese pizza - tomato sauce and mozzarella. Except, I didn’t use your standard Italian-inspired tomato sauce. Instead, I used a smokey and spicy tomato sauce from Caribbean cuisine called choka.
We first learned of choka 5 or 6 years ago when we started going to farmer’s markets on a regular basis in the summer. There was a booth that sold three different spiciness levels of choke which we quickly became addicted to. Mostly we ate it on our scrambled eggs on the weekends. And no, it was nothing like having salsa on your eggs. The flavor profile is unique and quite different from that of salsa. Sadly, for the last 2 or 3 years this booth has not been at the farmer’s markets. They do have a restaurant now so we had tried to buy some, but they said they don’t sell it anymore. If we ordered it a week ahead we could get some. It was unclear though if we would need to purchase the entire 10 pound batch they said they make so we haven’t ordered any.
Instead, I scoured the Internet for recipes. I came to the conclusion that there are as many choka recipes out there as there are meatloaf recipes. But, I found the process of one to be really clear and combined that recipe with some of the ingredients I knew to be a part of the one we had purchased. I didn’t quite hit the mark. There is some refining to do. But the result was still good on our scrambled eggs and was better than no choka or salsa. It was also an inspired pizza sauce! If you aren’t vegetarian I think I’d maybe add some grilled or shredded chicken or to get really crazy maybe a nice white-fleshed fish like tilapia and then squeeze a fresh lime over top right before eating it? Hmmm, I may have a new recipe to cook the next time I go back to MN and it is warm enough to grill!
This last pizza is not quite as unusual as the others we partook of that evening. It too was inspired by something we really enjoyed but could no longer get though! A regional pizza chain used to have a wild mushroom pizza that was really good. It wasn’t your garden variety white button mushrooms and it had garlic and rosemary flavor throughout. As seems to be the fate with many things we really like, it is no longer available. So, we used some of our often weekly mushroom mix from Hazel Dell and sauteed it with garlic and fresh rosemary at medium-low for a fairly long time. Like the eggplant pizza, we brushed the crust with garlic infused olive oil, then topped it with the mushroom, garlic and rosemary mixture. With this one we were a bit more generous on the mozzarella and added a bit of parmesan cheese as well. The result was delectable, and while simple, unlike any other dine-out or delivery pizza we’ve had besides the inspirational one.
Of the three of us, no one could choose a true favorite amongst the four pizzas. I do think it was a really nice mix of flavors. Each one quite a distinct palette experience. I think having the less challenging mushroom one was a good move. It was nice to have something a little more familiar and comfortable to visit. The lovely red wine brought by our guest paired quite nicely with all of them. I’m afraid though that I no longer recall what type of wine it was :-/ I really need to start keeping a wine and beer journal!
I realize this post may make me seem a bit pretentious in my pizza consumption. Let me assure you that this is not how we eat pizza every time we make it. But sometimes, especially when entertaining, it is nice to elevate a simple and universal food like pizza to a different level. To make the experience of eating it brand new. That said, I still crave a plain old sausage, pepperoni, onion, mushroom and green pepper pizza (and lately I’m loving banana peppers on it too). In fact, I indulged in one last Saturday evening.
How do you like your pizza? What is the most unusual pizza you’ve had?






















